Health insurance: The benefit that makes law firm owners need a doctor

Health insurance for law firmsOwning a law firm comes with plenty of headaches. Recruiting attorneys, managing employees, keeping clients satisfied, collecting receivables, monitoring billable hours, and making payroll are all part of the job. But one responsibility that has become particularly frustrating is providing health insurance to employees.

Most law firm owners went to law school to practice law. They did not go to medical school, become insurance brokers, or earn degrees in healthcare administration. Yet every year, they find themselves trying to understand deductibles, premiums, copays, coinsurance, provider networks, prescription coverage, and a seemingly endless collection of insurance acronyms.

Just when they think they have figured everything out, the renewal arrives. In some cases, employers face proposed increases of 10, 15, or even 20 percent. The insurance company may offer a modest reduction after negotiations, but the increase can still be substantial.

Think about that for a moment. How many law firms are growing their revenue by 20 percent annually? How many can increase their hourly rates by that much? How many can raise employee compensation by that percentage? For most firms, those numbers are unrealistic.

Yet health insurance premiums can increase at those rates, leaving law firm owners to figure out how to pay for them. It has become one of the most difficult expenses to manage, and the problem does not appear to be getting easier.

Health Insurance Costs Are Outpacing Law Firm Growth

The economics of running a law firm are already challenging. Law firms have to pay competitive salaries to attract and retain talented attorneys and staff. They have office expenses, technology costs, malpractice insurance, marketing expenses, payroll taxes, retirement contributions, and numerous other obligations.

Health insurance has become one of the fastest-growing and least predictable expenses. According to the KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey, employer-sponsored health insurance premiums have climbed into the thousands of dollars for individual coverage and tens of thousands of dollars for family coverage.

For perspective, the 2025 KFF survey reported average annual premiums of $9,325 for individual coverage and $26,993 for family coverage. Family premiums increased approximately 6 percent from the previous year. These are national averages, and individual employers can experience significantly larger increases.

Coverage or expenseAverage annual cost, 2025
Individual health insurance premium$9,325
Family health insurance premium$26,993
Average worker contribution, individual$1,440
Average worker contribution, family$6,850

These figures illustrate the substantial financial commitment associated with providing health insurance. Employers generally pay a significant portion of these premiums, and the cost can become enormous when multiplied across an entire law firm.

Consider a hypothetical law firm spending $500,000 annually on health insurance. A 10 percent increase means finding another $50,000. A 15 percent increase means another $75,000. A 20 percent increase means another $100,000, just to maintain essentially the same coverage.

That money has to come from somewhere. It might mean smaller raises, fewer hires, reduced profits, or increased costs passed along to clients. And it is not as though law firms can simply increase their hourly rates by 20 percent without consequences.

The Rule of Thirds Still Matters

One of the most important concepts in law firm management is the rule of thirds. Under this traditional approach, approximately one-third of revenue goes toward attorney compensation, one-third goes toward overhead, and one-third represents profit and the financial return for ownership risk.

It is a simplified model, and many modern law firms operate with different margins. Nevertheless, the principle remains important because law firms must balance compensation, operating expenses, and profitability to remain sustainable.

A firm cannot spend every dollar it collects on compensation and benefits while still having the resources necessary to operate, grow, and withstand difficult economic periods. Health insurance complicates this equation because the cost can grow much faster than the revenue supporting it.

When insurance expenses rise dramatically, the increase eats into the overhead portion of the equation. Eventually, it can begin consuming compensation dollars or profits as well. A firm with little profit has limited ability to invest in technology, hire additional attorneys, expand into new markets, or weather an unexpected downturn.

This is why understanding the economics of a law firm is so important. Financial management, growth, staffing, and profitability are recurring subjects on Law Firm Practice Management Advice. Health insurance belongs in that same conversation because benefits costs directly affect nearly every other financial decision an owner makes.

The Traditional Health Insurance Companies

Most law firm owners begin by looking at the traditional health insurance companies, including UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, and the various Blue Cross Blue Shield companies.

These insurers offer various forms of employer-sponsored coverage, including traditional PPO arrangements, high-deductible plans, and other network-based products. They have established provider networks, administrative systems, and experience working with employer groups. However, none is immune from rising healthcare costs.

The challenge becomes particularly complicated for law firms operating in multiple states. A plan that works well for employees in one state might not provide equally convenient access to doctors and hospitals in another.

For a multi-state law firm, network access is extremely important. An insurance policy that looks affordable on paper is not much of a benefit if employees cannot conveniently use it where they live.

Changing insurance companies can also create problems. Employees may have to find new doctors, change prescription arrangements, or deal with different deductibles and coverage requirements. That makes switching carriers much more complicated than simply choosing the lowest premium.

What About the Health Insurance Disruptors?

Fortunately, traditional insurance companies are no longer the only organizations trying to address the employer health insurance market. A growing number of companies are attempting to offer alternative approaches to healthcare benefits, and law firm owners should investigate whether these options could work for their organizations.

Companies worth examining include Gravie, Angle Health, Allied National, and Capital Health, including CapitolCare-related offerings. Other possibilities may involve alternative network arrangements, level-funded products, or plans using networks associated with companies such as Claritev.

Some of these organizations attempt to reduce costs through different funding models, administrative arrangements, or provider-payment structures. Others emphasize technology, simpler benefits administration, or more predictable employee expenses. Alternative arrangements associated with Capital Health and CapitolCare are among the options employers may wish to investigate when comparing traditional insurance with newer benefit models.

The potential savings can be substantial in some circumstances, particularly when compared with traditional insurance renewal increases. However, employers must examine the actual coverage, deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, provider networks, and prescription benefits before concluding that an alternative is better.

There is also an important catch. Not every company will insure every industry, and not every product is available in every state. Some alternative providers have underwriting restrictions that can make coverage difficult for certain professional-service businesses, including law firms.

For firms considering these alternatives, the questions go well beyond price. Will the insurer accept a law firm? Can it provide coverage across multiple states? Are the provider networks adequate? What happens when an employee has a major medical event? Are prescription benefits comparable? What financial exposure does the employer retain?

A lower premium is attractive, but it is not necessarily a better deal if employees lose meaningful coverage or the employer assumes risks it does not fully understand. Nevertheless, with traditional premiums continuing to rise, these newer alternatives deserve serious consideration.

The Self-Funding Question

Another possibility is self-funded or level-funded health insurance. Under a traditional fully insured arrangement, the employer pays premiums to an insurance carrier, which generally assumes the contractual risk of covered medical claims.

Under a self-funded arrangement, the employer assumes responsibility for paying covered claims, usually with a third-party administrator handling the plan. Employers can purchase stop-loss insurance to limit exposure to unusually large claims.

Level-funded arrangements attempt to provide more predictable monthly payments while incorporating elements of self-funding. These models can produce savings for certain employers, particularly those with favorable claims experience.

However, they are not a magic solution. A law firm with a relatively small employee population may have substantial claims volatility. A few serious medical conditions can dramatically affect costs, and employers must understand how stop-loss coverage, exclusions, renewals, and claims obligations work.

There are also administrative, compliance, cash-flow, and renewal considerations. A law firm owner already managing numerous operational responsibilities may reasonably question whether assuming additional insurance risk is worthwhile.

The possibility of saving money is appealing, but it needs to be balanced against the potential financial exposure.

Not Every Employee Values Health Insurance the Same Way

One of the most challenging aspects of providing employee benefits is that employees value them differently. Many younger employees, particularly those who are healthy and have few medical expenses, may place greater importance on their take-home pay.

Some would rather receive a larger paycheck than have the employer spend thousands of dollars on health insurance premiums. That does not mean younger employees do not care about insurance, but the perceived value can vary significantly depending on an employee’s circumstances.

Employees with children often view health insurance differently. They may be concerned about pediatric visits, emergency care, prescriptions, specialist appointments, and unexpected illnesses. Employees with chronic health conditions or significant medical needs may place an even greater value on comprehensive coverage.

For those employees, the quality of health insurance can be one of the most important factors in deciding whether to accept or remain in a job. The employer is trying to provide a benefit that works for everyone, but the employees do not necessarily want or need the same thing.

Some want the lowest possible premium. Others want the lowest deductible. Some want a broad network of doctors, while others want access to specific specialists or prescription medications. There is no single plan that makes everyone happy.

This is another reason why employee benefits must be considered as part of a law firm’s broader compensation and retention strategy. Recruiting and retaining good employees requires competitive compensation, but it also requires understanding what different employees actually value.

Are Health Savings Accounts Part of the Answer?

Health Savings Accounts, or HSAs, deserve serious consideration. An HSA allows eligible employees enrolled in qualifying high-deductible health plans to contribute money on a tax-advantaged basis for qualified medical expenses. Employers can also contribute to these accounts.

For 2026, the federal HSA contribution limits are $4,400 for self-only coverage and $8,750 for family coverage, with an additional $1,000 catch-up contribution for eligible individuals age 55 and older.

The advantage is that employees can use HSA funds for eligible medical expenses, carry unused balances forward, and potentially invest accumulated funds for future healthcare needs. Contributions, qualifying investment growth, and distributions for qualified medical expenses receive favorable federal tax treatment.

For younger and healthier employees, an HSA-compatible plan can be particularly attractive if the premiums are lower and the employee can build savings over time. However, HSAs are not necessarily the best solution for everyone.

An employee with children or significant ongoing medical expenses may be uncomfortable with a high deductible, particularly if the employer does not contribute enough to the HSA to help offset that exposure. A high-deductible plan can look inexpensive until someone actually needs substantial medical care.

That is why law firms should evaluate both premiums and potential out-of-pocket costs rather than simply selecting the plan with the lowest monthly payment. Offering multiple plan options, where practical, may be one way to accommodate different employee needs.

The IRS provides information about HSAs and other tax-favored health plans, which can help employers understand the applicable rules and limitations.

Should the Government Just Take Over Health Insurance?

This is where the discussion becomes politically complicated. Some people believe the United States should move toward a government-run or universal health insurance system that would reduce or eliminate the connection between employment and medical coverage.

There are legitimate arguments on both sides. From the perspective of a law firm owner, one potential advantage is obvious. Employers would no longer have to spend enormous amounts of time shopping for insurance, comparing plans, negotiating renewals, and trying to determine how to absorb annual premium increases, assuming the new system removed those responsibilities.

Law firm owners could spend more time practicing law, serving clients, developing attorneys, and running their businesses. The administrative burden of employer-sponsored insurance is significant, particularly for smaller firms that do not have large human resources departments.

But government-run healthcare also raises concerns. Who pays for it, and through what taxes? What happens to provider reimbursement? Would patients face longer waits for certain services? How much choice would people have regarding doctors, hospitals, and treatments?

And what about individuals who genuinely like their private health insurance? Many Americans value their existing coverage and would strongly oppose losing the ability to purchase private plans or choose among competing insurers.

There is also an important distinction between universal coverage and a system that eliminates private insurance. Not every universal healthcare model works the same way. A government-centered system could reduce the employer’s insurance burden while shifting costs elsewhere through taxes

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.